X-Entertainment.com X-Entertainment UGO
You are all doomed. Why not surrender? We might let you live.

05/21/2003: Who Was Photog?

Off in the far corners of Masters of the Universe lore lies Photog, the action figure Mattel ‘forgot’ to make. The character was a creation of a kid named Nathan Bitner – the winner of a grand contest where children plied their trade at drawing their own MOTU figure. According to the (disregarded) rules, Nathan was to have his figure forged by the thousands and put out for a national release. For whatever reason, it never happened. My best guess is that the character itself wouldn’t lend itself to easy production using older molds, and Mattel didn’t believe the extra money necessary to make Photog work was worth the risk. That’s pure speculation of course, but if true, it’s pretty silly. Nathan was eleven-years-old at the time of the contest – if anyone knew what kind of action figures kids wanted, I’d say it was him.

But who knows? Maybe Mattel found out he cheated or something. These days, Photog is about as obscure as it gets, and nobody really knows what happened to the poor guy. The only documentation available came on the last page of the Spring ‘86 issue of The Masters of the Universe Magazine, so today, we take a look back at that article and try to piece together this incredibly pointless mystery. It’s time we found out the truth. Who was Photog?

Believe it or not, the article fills in a lot of blanks. I was just expecting a few congratulatory remarks, and maybe some Nathan-brand quotes where he talks about how Orko is such a funny guy. Apparently, Nathan was awarded a scholarship for 100,000 dollars, plus a five-day trip to California. I dunno, sounds like hush money to me. I can just picture some shady Mattel exec offering the wad of dough to Nathan’s family before putting one of those iconic black mouse caps on his head, asking if he’d ever been on Space Mountain. In a flurry of confusion and newfound greed, everyone started signing papers until Photog’s promised production was null and void. If that’s the case, I hope Nathan had fun at Disneyland. Actually wait, no I don’t – that’d mean he screwed the world out of Photog. That blows. I hope the fine print read that the scholarship could be paid out in Monopoly money. Stupid kid.

On Photog, Nathan adds: “I thought the idea of making my character with camera features would be neat.” Sounds like something they made him say, all the while waving 100K checks and VIP passes to Epcot which didn’t even make sense since Epcot’s in Florida. That’s his only quote in the article, so I guess he’s about as good of an interview as Tara Reid.

Photog’s power was said to be the ability to ‘focus in’ on his enemies before draining their strength. The silhouettes shown on his chestplate are pictures of his fallen foes, proving Photog both a sadist and a pretty skilled photographer. The article closes out with a detailed list of Nate’s hobbies, but I stopped reading after I got to ‘doing puzzles’ since no hobby will ever top THAT. Even though the figure never made it to stores, the kid took in a hundred grand and a week-long date with Mickey for spending a few hours with paper and magic markers. I’d say that’s a decent haul. I’m sure the enthusiastic customs artist might be able to make a Photog figure – I’d try it myself, but I’m not a customs artist and I’m usually too busy trying to figure out a way to make plastic edible. That’s the story of Photog. I never said it was going to be long.


Posted by Matt. E-mail me!

Bookmark and Share


Discussion Thread: 2,402 comments

Happy Bitnermas to everyone…whew, I almost missed it and thanks for the anniversary comments…anyway, I was just wondering why Matt has never done an article on this page? I don’t know why the question has never been asked, but if he can write about American Gladiator snacks, he can find time to write about the blog that inspired a cult in excess of 2200 comments, at least 30 or 40 of which are mine…I demand an article. Happy Bitnermas and let us celebrate New Bitner Day six days hence, indeed making the year 2 P.B., although the chances of seeing 3 P.B. are slim indeed…

Ghosted by whitemale_98/competent soldier @ 05/21/2004 11:02 PM EDT


HOLY CRAP BITNER POSTED! I wish someone would have called me and told me. Thanks a lot guys :(

Ghosted by wack0 @ 05/22/2004 3:25 AM EDT


Wow! One whole year of Photog. Too bad Matt wouldn’t add the blog and Wack0’s info/petition site to the main page’s explorer bar (or what ever the proper term is).
http://x-entertainment.com/updates/entries/archives/00000153.html http://savephotog.tk
Please Matt, let Photog go out with a bang of new readers.

More importantly, thank you to Nathan, whitemale and the rest of the armed services.

Keep on keepin’ on to all Bitnerites!

Ghosted by microfiche @ 05/22/2004 3:57 AM EDT


Sorry to tell you microfiche, but I took down that save Photog site a long time ago, as it was killing my bandwidth :\

Ghosted by wack0 @ 05/22/2004 4:23 AM EDT


wack0, then the Internet Yzzerdd must have kept it going for you: http://savephotog.tk and/or
http://northeastcustoms.net/wack0/photog.html
(Internet Yzzerdd is from Aqua Teen Hunger Force. Beware of pop-ups: http://www.yzzerdd.com)

If people are wondering why I posted the url for this blog in the blog; it is not I am just slow, which I am. It was my plan to post it in the latest blog thread to get some new readers and hopefully get Matt to consider a front page mention, but I got the open windows mixed up.

Ghosted by microfiche @ 05/22/2004 5:43 AM EDT


Seriously, don’t go to yzzerdd.com, unless you have a program (In my case a cleaning one) that can shut down your browser, because even disconnecting will not stop the pop-ups.

That site is an extended joke based off the episode where pop-ups ads start filling the characters house and there is no way to stop them.

Ghosted by microfiche @ 05/22/2004 5:58 AM EDT


o wow, guess i thought i took it down, yet didnt. well thats cool, it sure isnt hurting my bandwidth now, and it sure is a sucky website.

Ghosted by wack0 @ 05/22/2004 6:40 AM EDT


It is not sucky, wack0. When people want to know about Photog, I send them to your site. It would be great if you could update it. I feel bad that the petition did not get a push from X-E and He-Man.org. I understand though that Matt has his reasons, and He-Man.org is still in business with Mattel.

Ghosted by microfiche @ 05/22/2004 4:00 PM EDT


Wow, I suck.
Not only have I not been here in about two months but I completely missed the anniversary.
I hang my head in shame…

If I can make it up to you let me know.

My humble apologies.

Ghosted by Tessie @ 05/22/2004 9:08 PM EDT


Am I…..Am I late?

Guess so.

Well, big N, what a ride, man, what a ride.

Should I close the door on my way out?

Ghosted by Sirkus Peanuts @ 05/22/2004 9:37 PM EDT


NOTE: This post intentionally left blank.

Ghosted by Jim Robinson @ 05/23/2004 5:56 PM EDT


NOTE: This post intentionally left blank.

Ghosted by Jim Robinson @ 05/23/2004 5:56 PM EDT


NOTE: This post intentionally left blank.

Ghosted by Jim Robinson @ 05/23/2004 5:56 PM EDT


Guys, Guys!!! You didn’t miss anything…Everyone knows there are eight days of Bitnermas that represent the eight plites of Nathan! Special bonus points if you can name all eight!

Ghosted by Stilewalker @ 05/24/2004 8:38 AM EDT


That’s plight, not plite.

Ghosted by Stilewalker @ 05/24/2004 8:45 AM EDT


Is Bitner Jewish?

Hmmm, let me see the 8 plights of Bitner:

Bankruptcy
Delusions of Grandeur
Insanity
Deployment
Rejection
Infamy(what is that? that means he is more than famous!)
Betrayal
Unemployment

I think that is a pretty good starter list…

Ghosted by whitemale_98/competent soldier @ 05/24/2004 5:42 PM EDT


Damn… a year later and all this crap has gone by. I ain’t reading all this! Anyone care to rundown what’s happened since I last posted… ohhhh… 1900 posts ago??? haha

Ghosted by Prezkot @ 05/25/2004 1:43 PM EDT


I just found X-E off of maddox’s site (maddox.xmission.com) and stumble upon this.

I read the whole thing, every last post. The ups and downs. Simply amazing, one of the best things I’ve ever read on the internet, simple as that.

I was a huge Motu fan back in the day, when I was a kid.

I guess all in all, thanks for the great great great great read.

This should get more press coverage. If my school’s newspaper wasn’t going to press tommorrow and if I wasn’t graduating next month, I’d write about it.

Maybe I will write about it in a publication.

thanks. Maybe I’ll look again one day.

Ghosted by James @ 05/25/2004 10:17 PM EDT


Well, damn. I missed out on the past 368 days of Bitnermania.

Looking back on this great trek you’ve all embarked upon since my last (and first) post on Day 3 of the Bitner Experience, I’ve gotta say you’re all just a little crazy. But hey, that’s what I love about it.

Ghosted by Sammich King @ 05/26/2004 11:05 AM EDT


Hey …. where ….? Last thing I knew I was drinking heavily at the Bitnemas party. That was 6 days ago. Oh man, next year I gotta tone it dwon.

Ghosted by Gozer @ 05/27/2004 7:27 PM EDT


i read this site for the first time about two weeks ago, and, needless to say, i was amazed by the story. i told all of my friends the story, in explicit detail.

okay…this next part is going to sound completely fucked, but here goes…
i was at a thrift store earlier this evening in a nearby town (chatham, ontario, canada), and was looking through some stuff. i picked up a pretty nondescript black t-shirt that looked to be in pretty good condition. i looked at the tag and my jaw dropped. it had "N. Bitner" sewed on the tag. i did a doubletake for sure. i showed my friend, who said, "…the photog dude?". we then looked through the rack, to find that nearly every item of clothing on it had the same thing sewed on. i bought the t-shirt, just to be like, "man. i’m wearing nathan bitner’s shirt."i don’t know if it’s really THE NATHAN Bitner, but it seemed pretty messed up regardless.

Ghosted by bruce @ 05/28/2004 10:34 PM EDT


Bruce you’ve stumbled upon the holy shroud of Bitner, I suggest you start a small resteraunt and use the clothes of the man to attract business.
Oh and ME that Rance cat can’t hold a candle to Bitner. Rance better watch out or Photog might show up and just rock Rance’s socks right off (and not in a good way)

Ghosted by Tornado @ 05/29/2004 2:46 AM EDT


Bruce….
I would SO pay for that shirt.
Any plans on making a deal for it?
Because that is truly amazing – our Bitner’s or not.

Ghosted by Denise @ 05/29/2004 1:45 PM EDT


Wow, Nates got his own brand of clothes, sweet. I see the world domination thing is coming along nicely.

Starts out at Stage 1: As a small boy create the ultimate action figure and expose the inbred corruption of an evil corporation.

Stage 2: After several years of being pulled off-track through personal crisis, gain a good knowledge of computer programming and technological expertise while under the guise of a fledgling games developer.

Stage 3: Explore the world of the armed forces and gain valuable military expertise and a list of powerful contacts of the worlds most dangerous men.

Stage 4: Recruiting an ever growing band of loyal, if slightly mal-adjusted, followers.

Then comes Stage 5: domination of the various global markets, slowly building up a vast fortune to fund stage 6.

Stage 6: Bring all parts of it together. Band together all followers on different continents each led by an expert in warfare from the military days.
Use the vast monetary resources to develop new and ingenious weapons and tools with the technical know-how combined with research and development labs set up in the heart of the now Bitner-owned Mattel corporation. A hollow outer shell sustaining the toy-producing image, masking Nate’s Headquaters in all of the different Mattel global locations. France, Europe, Canada, Australia, Mexico, and various US based ”outlets”.

Stage 7: World domination through a mix of; overwhelming numbers of armed followers, hi-tech weather-machines, earthquake inducing drills and giant lasers suspended in planetary orbit, and life size photog inspired cyborgs.

Ghosted by [ Matt-The-Gr7 ] @ 05/30/2004 10:01 AM EDT


Speaking of which, if you want to get a head start and take down Mattel from the inside, check out their website and all the ‘Job Opportunities’.

http://sh.webhire.com/Public/321/

Such as the ‘Security Officer – El Segundo, CA’
Under Responsibilities it states:
"Operate Mattel worldwide command center".

Ghosted by [ Matt-The-Gr7 ] @ 05/30/2004 10:08 AM EDT


Looks like you’ve been up to some serious plotting, Matt-The-Gr7. :)

Ghosted by Denise @ 05/30/2004 11:33 PM EDT


For the love of all things Bitner!- I can’t believe I finally got through 2000 and then some posts, to remain completely unfulfilled! Where is this Bitner?! Why do you torture us so with your incessant avoidance?? Man, I was all ready with the wine and ritualistic sacrifices for the Church of Bitner too, damn shame… I started reading this last night at work (and thanks to all of you there’s one night audit that ISN’T getting done thoroughly tonight either) when I found Matt’s site by searching for information on how to obtain an old school Fortress Maximus (not the cheesy Japanese rip-off tyvm) for my boyfriend. Will Transformer obsession stop at nothing?? Anywho, I’m sorry to have come in so late in the game, I actually got really excited when I first started reading thinking "I must join in the search for Bitner-dome"…until I noticed that the dates were from May 2000-THREE dammit. Anyway, I hope you don’t take the blog down, maybe you should submit it to the Guinness book of World Records, how sweetass would that be? One day Nathan Bitner’s perusing the tech-section (is there even one?) of the World Records book and stumbles upon none other than his name, his legacy, his love… Sounds like a diabolical plan to me, so Bitner..

Ghosted by Baba Ganoush @ 05/31/2004 2:49 AM EDT


Save Photog. ;-;

Ghosted by Vidd @ 05/31/2004 12:07 PM EDT


We’ve already found Bitner.

Ghosted by Lincoln @ 05/31/2004 2:46 PM EDT


First post in June…always finding new ways to celebrate, besides if 21 May is BitnerMas, 1 June is of course New Bitner Day. Huzzah! Huzzah!

PS–Just always wanted to proclaim Huzzah, thanks.

Ghosted by whitemale_98/competent soldier @ 06/01/2004 11:36 AM EDT


Awww. Today is the one year anniversary of my first post here.
<3

Ghosted by Denise @ 06/01/2004 7:14 PM EDT


Where in among all this are Bitner’s posts? :D

Ghosted by Kev @ 06/01/2004 10:02 PM EDT


November 28th, I believe.
And yeah. It’s only one.

Ghosted by Denise @ 06/02/2004 4:42 PM EDT


Holy! A six day gap. Is that the longest ever?

Ghosted by notbob @ 06/08/2004 8:34 PM EDT


Don’t let the blog die like this…even though we’re really at a dead end…

Ghosted by whitemale_98/competent soldier @ 06/10/2004 5:55 PM EDT


Well, there are still some things we could do.

Like how they invented the word quiz. Some guy in London bet another guy that he couldn’t introduce a new word into the English language. So the other guy accepted the bet, and spraypainted the word "quiz" all over London.

The next morning, everybody was asking what quiz meant, and it was of course a puzzlement and quite the question, earning it the meaning it has now.

Bottom line: I’m not saying we should commit any acts of vandalism, but I am saying that we should spread the word through creative means.

Anybody own a small plane and about 80 feet of durable plastic banner?

Ghosted by Sirkus Peanuts @ 06/10/2004 9:26 PM EDT


I’m not sure if the Chicago/UNC thing was ever cleared up, but I found an article that does. Bitner left UC, without his degree, to go to work for Bungie with his former roommate. He then left there to finish his B.A. at UNC. He may have been working on a master’s. Someone should look up his thesis. This links the suicide Bitner to the Bungie one.

"I left Bungie to finish my B.A. in psychology. The Masters classes in testing and pharmacology seemed to be skipping a step. Damn thesis."

You can read the whole article at http://web.archive.org/web/20010628093420/http://gamesmania.com/html/interviews/show.asp?file=interview21
They also have a picture of him there from 2001.
http://web.archive.org/web/20010808122916/gamesmania.com/image.asp?ImageURL=/html/interviews/images/bitner.jpg

The article also mentions several military people that he has worked with. This could explain why he joined the army. He may have gotten along well with that kind of people so the army would be a logical place for him to run to.

Ghosted by PHILVID2 @ 06/10/2004 11:00 PM EDT


Inspired by the last post I realised in allmy googling of Nate, I never googled his name under the image search.
Try it, at my count i got 759 results with a diverse and often worrying variety of results.

including:
a dance troupe, a number of ‘pretender to the name’ mugshots of dudes who all seem to look vaguely alike(balding seems to be a running trend), a suprising ammount of gravestones, at least one convict, an aardvark, a male model, and http://www.bitners.com a wholesale crystal, rock and mineral supplier.

wyrd.

Ghosted by [ Matt-The-Gr7 ] @ 06/14/2004 3:48 PM EDT


When Fearless Photog failed to show in stores the next year, I referred tothe contest’s rules (printed with the contest’s announcement in the Sundaycomics section, September 8, 1985). They state:

"The Winning Entry will be made into an actual Toy!!!"

The operative word being "an". Apparantly, this Nathan Bitner received aone-of-a-kind prototype of his creation, Fearless Photog. And the rest ofus? Oh, well, it was still a cool contest.

Ghosted by Orion @ 06/15/2004 2:38 AM EDT


That’s so bitner.

Ghosted by Denise @ 06/15/2004 5:18 PM EDT


Orion – Nope, Nathan never got his Photog figure. He did supposedly receive a poloroid of a green and pink prototype. However, this picture has never surfaced and many he-fans have been wanting to see this for years..

Ghosted by Dr. Omega @ 06/17/2004 11:54 AM EDT


It’s been a while…..

I think you guys said Bitner was in the military? Although I met countless Marines and Sailors during Fleet Week through the USO, I can say that sadly, I did not meet him. Actually it’s a good thing- it would’ve been too f’ing weird for me!

Oh and P.S. Netossa is resting comfortably in my bookcase.

Ghosted by Josette @ 06/20/2004 2:23 AM EDT


Jeebus.

Over a year. I remember last summer telling friends about this… and them not caring.

I still don’t think they care.

But I do! Sort of… huh. Maybe I don’t. Don’t care about the figure, I mean, not the cause.

The movement is beautiful, and insane.

Shine on you crazy diamonds.

Ghosted by Ed Franklin @ 06/21/2004 4:14 PM EDT


Bitner lives on

Ghosted by Jim Robinson @ 06/21/2004 11:37 PM EDT


Josette, not to be a jerk, but your post reminded me of one of my favorite quotes from the forgotten Spielberg film.

Ned Beatty’s character feels guilty about being too old to serve and gives a quick talk to his daughter:
[To Betty, before she leaves for the USO.]
Ward Douglas: I don’t know what they’ve told you down at the USO, but you’re going to be meeting a lot of strange men. Men in uniform. Boys a long way from home, lonely, desperate. They really have one thing on their minds. Show ‘em a good time.

Ghosted by Fan of 1941 @ 06/23/2004 7:01 PM EDT


Bitner lives within all of us.

Ghosted by Mr. Geist @ 06/24/2004 2:42 AM EDT


Christ… after reading for nearly seven hours, I’ve reached the end.

In a way, it almost feels like walking into a bar at closing time – the music’s still playing and the doors are open, but the lights are up, the barstools are mostly put away, and the few strangling barmaids are cleaning empty bottles and peanut shells up off the floor. It’s pretty damn clear there was one HELL of a good time had by all, but it’s also just as clear it’s more or less over. You don’t have to go home, but you can’t stay here…

So why am I posting? Well, clearly, SOME people are still drifting in and out, including some of the hardened veterans. Maybe Nathan himself (if that really was him – we’ll never know for 100% sure) still pulls the page up when he gets a chance, to see what’s being said (though, probably not – if I were in his place, I’d probably be too weirded out. Then again, I’m paranoid enough to want to keep an eye on things). But mostly, because I think it falls to someone like me – someone who saw the rise, the peak, and the fall, all in one sitting – to provide a fitting coda.

I came at this from a different angle than many of you – I’d never heard of the MOTU contest back in ‘86 (though I would have been 9 at the time), I’d never heard of X-E before, and no one sent me along via word of mouth. No, in my case, it was playing Halo, slowly getting into the storyline, then eventually learning of its links to an earlier Bungie game – Marathon. That, in turn, eventually led me to the Cortana Letters.

I found myself interested in the man who had developed such an interesting marketing tool, and wondered what he might be doing, what company he might be working for these days. That, in turn, brought me to mentions of Island Four, and eventually, to Tim Wilk’s old forums post about Nathan’s self-destructive ways. What happened after that, I wondered? Was he still on the run? Had his downward spiral culminated in that final, fatal rock-bottom? Or had he found a way to pick himself up and become a better man? And so, I did a search for his name on Yahoo… and after a few false leads and dead links, I find myself here.

What is it about this man that confounds us so, forcing us to seek answers?

Like some people have said before, there’s just something about Nathan Bitner (a new Farrelly Brothers movie?) that seems to inspire the puzzle-solving skills – from the old-school Bungie fans trying to piece together the meaning of the Cortana Letters, to fans trying to figure out just what was going to happen with Island Four, to this blog – a desperate search for a man who once won a MOTU contest when he was 11-years old.

Why do we feel so driven?

For myself, it’s a question I can’t really answer, other than suggesting my mildly obsessive nature might encourage me to tie-off such a blatant loose end. Or maybe it was the fact that I can see shades of my own life reflected in him. At least a few people have semi-jokingly suggested there’s a touch of Bitner in all of us… and maybe they’re right. Maybe we care because we can look at this man, who’s seen highs and lows both, and think – "There, but for the grace of God, goes I". But regardless of the reasons, the Search began. And the Search is over.

As I started reading, each new detail discovered led me to hope that he would be found, while every setback deflated me a little. As days went by with no leads, and it began to seem as if the search would end in failure, hope began to turn to resignation and disappointment. He’s not going to be found… or if he is, he’s not going to reply. Can you blame him?

And yet, he WAS found. He DID reply.

It’s possible that the Nathan Bitner who responded was a fake, that "Anonymous", who IDed him, might be fake as well, created just to validate the reply that was soon to follow. For that matter, any number of others could have been fake – Tim Wilk, the other contest winners, people who added fuel to the fire, or subtly diverted the topic (I swear, for a while, I was wondering if Ghost of Vapor might not be Bitner, throwing us off the scent with all his artwork). Whoever came up with the Descarte reference first nailed it dead-on – how CAN we accept that what we see and hear is real, and not just deception?

But, it FEELS right. We WANT it to be him. And, beyond continuing to try and mail the Nathan Bitner whose address in the military has been found, all avenues to decisively proving it have been exausted. In the end, it’s simply up to each and every person to decide what to believe.

Me? I choose to believe that someone who had been given a chance to succeed nearly lost everything, but that – judging from the tone and content of his reply – has found a way to come back from adversity. Someone who, when all is said and done, might just come out ahead. For all the talk of Bitner-as-Messiah that was jokingly floated early on, maybe his story DOES have something to teach us.

It’s such a perfect conclusion, we’d hate to ruin it by doubting if that really was him or not. After all, it was the ending we were secretly hoping for from the beginning. Wishes really DO come true.

Or, as they say in Italian, "Se non è vero, è ben trovato" – "Even if it’s not true, it’s a wonderful invention".

Last one out, turn the lights off when you leave.

Ghosted by Paranoid Obsessive @ 06/25/2004 2:33 AM EDT


A DEMAND some sort of a recap post by Matt on this MASSIVE blog. That would be so… rad.

Ghosted by West @ 06/25/2004 10:37 PM EDT


Welcome welcome, one and all.

Ghosted by Lincoln @ 06/26/2004 5:45 PM EDT


Add A New Comment!